No super-coating it yet – Second try with supercoated carbon tissue

My first try with supercoated carbon tissue didn’t work as it should. Here’s a second experiment – which again isn’t successful. But failures are progress, too!

This is a continuation of my previous blog on the issue, so I’ll lazily refer you to that one for the introduction of this concept.

In the interim, I made a post on Photrio about my ‘progress’. Moreover, I reached out to Calvin to ask his thoughts. Let me preface this blog by stating that there’s an obvious problem with the tests I’ll show below that I was aware of as I prepared them. As a result, I’m not too worried about the sorry results for now. They can still help understand parts of what’s going on – or should be.

To start with the glaring issue: it’s the gelatin. Calvin is clear on stating that the gelatin used for the supercoat needs to be about one stop faster than the gelatin used for the image layer below. I still need to sit down and think about this from a theoretical perspective, but so far, my understanding/guess is that this speed difference is to ensure that the supercoat hardens during exposure and thus offers a robust platform for the image to transfer on top of.

First, to get this out of the way: yes, the gelatin as such has an innate speed. This can be tested by taking several different gelatins and making otherwise identical tissues with them. Which is what I did, with the three gelatins I have on hand. One is a particularly nasty, technical grade gelatin and it just didn’t produce a workable print with DAS to begin with, so that one is out. The other two are the GMW Photo Restoration #2 gelatin and a food-grade, bovine gelatin I buy from a food additive/ingredient wholesaler.

The former, the GMW gelatin, is a really nice gelatin to work with – high gel strength, fairly clear/colorless, no nasty bits etc. It’s a porcine gelatin, so it reeks a little under certain circumstances, but for carbon transfer, it’s a solid performer. It’s the gelatin I use 95% of the time. The food-grade, bovine gelatin I used here is the gelatin I used to use back when I started with carbon transfer. It’s also a very good performer, but much more colored than the Photo Restoration gel and with a slightly lower bloom. It’s a little easier to work with (melts more readily) and it smells kind of nice. I did a speed test with both of these gelatins. Which is to say, I cooked up some tissues with them, using the same recipe, and making two prints with identical exposures with them:

The Photo Restoration porcine gel is on the left, the food-grade bovine on the right. The negative is a Fomapan 200 4×5″ neg exposed at around EI100 that I developed for around 5 minutes in ID62 developer (1+2 dilution or thereabouts). The print exposure consisted of two parts: a 365nm highlight exposure followed by a 395nm shadow exposure. Remember the purpose here was to speed test the gelatins with the hope to find a significant speed difference. Alas:

Above is a HD plot of both of these prints based on measurements from the Stouffer step tablets. As you can see, there’s no significant difference in speed. The food-grade gelatin may or may not be a fraction of a stop faster – but even if it is, the difference is too small for the purpose of a supercoat gelatin pair.

I may have to bite the bullet on that Photo Restoration #1 gelatin. No, I’ve not ordered it yet.

Deciding to do some testing with what I had on hand, I proceeded with just the Photo Restoration #2 gelatin. I made some tissues with this gelatin – specifically three variants, all with the same formulation for the image/base layer:

  • A plain image layer tissue without any supercoat
  • A supercoated tissue with an unsensitized top layer
  • A supercoated tissue with a top layer sensitized with 6% w/w DAS (i.e. 6% of the gelatin weight in that layer).

I figured this would at least show the effect of having the supercoat – and I also figured that even without a proper speed matching between the gelatins, there might be a benefit to having the supercoat. Well, see for yourself:

Left to right: non-supercoated tissue, non-sensitized supercoat, sensitized supercoat

The non-sensitized supercoat tissue essentially shows no highlights at all in this print. They’re all gone, flaked away. The print on the right with the sensitized supercoat retains some highlights, but much of it is gone. The print on the left retains some of the highlights on the stairs, but those on the wall on the left are gone; this is the print without a supercoat.

The fact that the supercoated tissues retain less of the highlight tonal scale is not so much a problem – in fact, it seems plausible. With an extra (thin) layer of gelatin on top, it seems to make sense that a little more exposure is needed to print through this layer. So a slight shift in tonal scale isn’t so much of an issue. More relevant is the transition between the highlights and pure white. I see virtually no difference in this regard between the prints if I look closely. There’s a clear tonal threshold on each of the prints.

The prints above are actually the second comparison set I made with these tissues. The first was made with a negative with a much longer tonal scale and consequently a far heavier exposure (especially the 365nm highlight exposure). The negative was made at the same time as the one I used for the prints above and processed in the same way, but I also intensified it. Redevelopment was done in a staining developer (pyrocat HD) and the resulting UV density is significantly beyond 3.0logD. Here are those prints:

The order is again the same; non-supercoated tissue, unsensitized supercoat, sensitized supercoat. Note that the pattern to the highlights is also the same as shown earlier, so nothing new here. The main difference with the earlier set is that the dense areas are lacking in part or even for the most part (esp. on the print with the unsensitized supercoat).

The main culprit here is that the image layer of the tissue is eerily thin. I followed Calvin’s tissue formulation (although I used a different pigment; Kremer XSL black instead of Talens India ink), which he mentions is similar to what he uses for halftone screen negatives. The shadow exposure in this case went straight through the tissue, resulting in the darkest bits not transferring to the temporary support sheet and instead adhering to the Yupo tissue support in a few places, causing flagging and further loss of these areas.

Moreover, on the tissue with the unsensitized supercoat, the problem was exacerbated by the supercoat that apparently didn’t harden as well as it could and therefore didn’t offer sufficient support to curb the issue. On the earlier print with the reduced exposure (and thinner negative) I also spotted a single place where the black band on top started to flag with only that tissue (unsensitized supercoat).

For now, my conclusion is that the speed difference between the gelatins is probably quite crucial. Calvin indicated on the basis of my first test that this is likely the cause of the failures I’m seeing. Coincidentally, he also confirmed that the supercoat is supposed to ‘sensitize itself’ as it’s poured on top of the image layer, due to DAS diffusing from the bottom layer into the thin top layer. Moreover, he said that the supercoat can also be sensitized, but that he omits this step just to keep the process simple. My testing above suggests that it does make a difference, but sensitizing the supercoat apparently doesn’t eliminate the need for a speed difference between the gelatins.

To be continued.

Oh, and to keep my spirits up, I printed the beefier negative with an intent to transfer to a proper final support. I made these prints with my regular thick tissue which I know performs fairly well with regard to highlight retention. Here are the prints still on their temporary supports. Check the delicate highlights especially on the print on the left. Not bad.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *